Out of the total 154 state-owned companies monitored by the Government and the International Monetary Fund, 59 posted losses between 1,000 lei per employee (EUR231) and as much as RON883,000 per employee at Uzina Mecanica Orastie, a weapons factory that branched out from Romarm and was included in a restructuring program nearly ten years ago, with no end in sight.
Other companies with considerable losses are SN Carbunelui (RON359,000 per employee), SC Carbonifera (RON238,000 per employee), Termoelectrica (RON203,000 per employee), Santierul Naval Mangalia (RON181,000 per employee), Tarom (RON163,000 per employee), Romavia (RON144,000 per employee), CN Huilei (RON72,000 per employee), Oltchim (RON60.000 per employee), Avioane Craiova (RON54,000 per employee), CNM Petromin (RON52,000 per employee), CN CFR (RON41,000 per employee), CFR Marfa (RON29,000 per employee), SN Radiocomunicatii (RON20,000 per employee), Metrorex (RON14,000 per employee), SNLO (RON6,000 per employee), Posta Romana (RON3,000 per employee), CFR Calatori (RON3,000 per employee), Regia Patrimoniului Protocolului de Stat (RON3,000 per employee), according to a study by the World Bank.
By comparison, last year, each private sector employee produced, on average, before-tax profit of RON370, while each state-owned company employee contributed to a loss of RON7,000 in local branches and RON22,000 on a central level.
Of the 154 monitored companies, only 31 posted profit per employee above the national average and only 14 posted profits above the private sector average.
Companies that control the market on their segment also recorded profits, as was the case with Electrica (RON599,000 per employee), Imprimeria Nationala (RON229,000 per employee), CN Aeroporturi Bucuresti (RON87,000 per employee), Transgaz (RON81,000 per employee), Loteria Romana (RON66,000 per employee), Hidroelectrica (RON15,000 per employee) and Nuclearelectrica (RON13,000 per employee).
The study also says that a third of state-owned enterprises, which employ over 116,000 people, are considered practically, though not legally, bankrupt, as they are responsible for 67% of arrears, but continue to receive 37% of the total value of state subsidies.
The list of companies considered “de facto” bankrupt and nonviable includes RADET, CFR SA, Oltchim, CFR Marfa, Termoelectrica, CN Huilei, CET Iasi, Electrocentrale Oradea, CET Brasov and Apaterm.
CFR Calatori, RADET Constanta, Regia de Termoficare Craiova, Regia de Transport Timisoara, Regia de Transport Brasov, Romavia, Regia de Drumuri Valcea, Urbis, Braicar and Cuprumin are also considered bankrupt, but for the time being still viable.
Other nonviable companies, but whose problems can be solved, include Compania Nationala de Autostrazi si Drumuri Nationale (the National Roads and Highways Company), Fortus, Goscom, Hidro Prahova, Romarm-Uzina Mecanica Bucuresti, SN Îmbunatatiri Funciare, Ecoterm, Confort Urban, Regia Domeniului Public Cluj-Napoca.
On the opposite end of the spectrum, responsible for only 9% of the total arrears and receiving 26% of the total subsidies, are enterprises deemed “healthy and efficient,” but which encounter low competition in their field, such as energy companies Romgaz, Transelectrica, Hidroelectrica, Electrocentrale Bucuresti, Nuclearelectrica, and Loteria Romană, Transgaz, the Craiova and Turceni energy complexes, Romsilva.
The document also says state-owned enterprises are less capable to carry out investments, less efficient and less focused on performance than the private sector, with lower profitability, leading to lower capacity to pay debts. Arrears in the private sector are more smoothly distributed than in the public sector; the ratio of arrears to turnover is much higher in the case of state-owned companies.
The state companies with the highest arrears at the beginning of this year are CFR SA (RON5.1 billion), CN Huilei (RON4.8 billion), Termoelectrica (RON3 billion), Oltchim (RON1.1 billion), CNADNR (RON1 billion), CFR Marfa (RON906 million), CFR Calatori (RON555 million), CFR Electrificare (RON537 million) and Electrocentrale Bucuresti (RON535 million). The situation is similar to that of past years, despite the Government’s commitment to reduce arrears. The companies’ debts are mainly to their suppliers and to the state budget.
The 760 state-owned companies reported RON53.9 billion turnover last year, the equivalent of 5.9% of the GDP. The value added by these companies was RON45 billion, 11% of the national economy’s total. Their combined arrears were worth RON28 billion, 28.8% of the economy’s total. The state companies last year employed 413,859 people, or 10% of the total number of employees in the country.
In the fall of 2009, after reorganizing the governmental agencies, the Executive announced it would launch a similar process to restructure, merge or close the companies and autonomous administrations owned entirely by the state, to limit their losses, which amounted to more than RON4.8 billion at the end of 2008. So far, the only steps taken by the authorities have been increasing the budgets of several ministries to repay these companies’ debts.
Jeffrey Franks, head of the IMF evaluation mission, has said several times that the outstanding debts of state-owned companies, amounting to 5% of the GDP, are a major hindrance to economic growth and that he will work with the Government towards a comprehensive solution.
The Government has committed to reducing the budget deficit to below 3% next year, including the losses of certain state-owned companies. This is also a condition for the termination of the European Commission’s excessive deficit procedure, opened against Romania in 2009.
In the latest letter of intent signed with the IMF, the Government has reduced the list of state-owned companies whose losses are taken into account when calculating next year’s deficit budget, from 30 to only 10, by eliminating the airports and local heating distributors (CET).
(EUR1=RON4.3288)