Despite its restructuring efforts, the EUR1 billion cash injection from the government in 2009 and the recent sale of the subsidiary network in the region (except for Romania) to Russia’s Sberbank, Volksbank Austria turns out to be a really costly disaster of a bank for taxpayers.
The Austrian govenrment decided to save Volksbank regardless of political disputes and reservations voiced by some of the leaders of the country’s banking system, by becoming a direct shareholder of the lender and injecting EUR250 million into it. The operation should be validated by the general meeting of the shareholders on Thursday. Volksbank Austria posted more than EUR1.3 billion in losses last year, partly because of the Romanian subsidiary.
Volksbank is the second major euro zone bank after Dexia saved by the government like this, as politicians felt it is worth spending public funds even though it is eventually about covering some serious management errors and distorting the much lauded free competition.
Volksbank Romania is surrounded by uncertainty. The bank was moved to a separate vehicle, VBI Beteiligungs GmbH, where Volksbank Austrian owns 51%, German-held DZ Bank 16.36% and French Banque Populaire et Caisse d’Epargne (BPCE) holds 24.5%. Another German bank, WGZ Bank (affiliated to the DZ group) owns 8.14%.
According to information on the market, Russia’s Sberbank did not want the Romanian subsidiary of Volksbank because it did not want to take on the massive funding needs of a bank that had operated as a loan shop for years, neglecting to attract resources from clients, as any bank should do.
The priority in Vienna has been to save Volksbank Austria until now. Once its situation cleared up, it will be time to make a decision about the subsidiary in Bucharest. The Austrian owner would be happy to sell, but no one is interested for the same reason the Russians were not. A solution might be selling loan packages as the bank’s portfolio is made up of mortgage loans mostly.
Banking sources say DZ Bank is currently supervising the operational management of Volksbank Romania. DZ Bank itself indicated it planned to retain its indirect stake in the local bank, as well as in its leasing subsidiary. The French bank is not interested and moved its stake in Volksbank from its commercial bank to its “equity interests” division.
(English version by Loredana Fratila-Cristescu)