The labor market needed as many as 21 months to recover after the government decided to increase the VAT level as of July 1, 2010, as it tried to boost budget revenue in order to meet the deficit targets agreed with the International Monetary Fund.
As a result of the sales tax increase in a year when the gross domestic product growth was seen up 1.5%, the economy fell abruptly, and 2010 ended with a GDP contraction of 1.6%.
The economic troubles were immediately felt on the labor market. In July 2011, the number of employees stood at 4.24 million, as the VAT hike had led to a decline by more than 16,000 employees compared with the previous month.
The executives that have had to resort to layoffs in the last period are not too optimistic about the performance of the economy in the second half of 2012 and do not think the number of new jobs will increase that much over the coming period.
“We did not lay people off when the government decided to hike the VAT but sales plunged and we cut down on our profit margin to be able to keep the same number of employees. Things have not improved, on the contrary, this year is the first when I’m seriously considering layoffs,” said Florin Rizea, general manager of Meda Prod 98, one of the top twenty cold cuts producers on the local market. Rizea runs a business that posted revenue of EUR24 million in 2012 and has more than 460 employees now.
“We laid off people in 2012, too, and this year’s budget includes 30 job cuts, as a result of the dwindling consumer spending and the increase in the operating expenses. We had successfully streamlined the company before the VAT hike in 2010, we took steps to cut costs but these steps, even though beneficial, were not enough to keep profitability at the same level as previously,” said Constantin Tudorache, general manager of Sarantis, owner of cosmetics producer Elmiplant. “We made layoffs but at the same time gave the employees left a 5.5% raise on the average in 2010.”
Even though Romania has a low jobless rate compared with other European countries (4.7% compared with 24.1% in Spain, 10.1% in Poland or 10.2% the average unemployment rate in the EU) the number of unemployed reported by the National Employment Agency does not accurately reflect those who are past collection of jobless benefits and no longer want to register to show up in the authorities’ records. Almost 600,000 unemployed people stopped being included in statistics in 2010, because they did not renew their applications for new jobs with the employment agencies and therefore are no longer officially recorded.
The number of employees in the economy has been on the rise since February 2011, at a rate of tens of thousands of people a month, but this market rebound in statistics is not showing in some of the sectors of the economy.
Between March 2011 and March 2012, the number of employees in the economy rose by more than 140,000, all of whom hired by the private sector, especially in the industry.
“The VAT hike affected our company’s economic performance, because the purchasing power of the people was limited and did not keep up with inflation. Although not directly connected to the VAT hike, we laid off 150 people last year to improve the ‘labor productivity’ indicator but at the same time hired another 150 people to expand our operations,” said Grigore Horoi, chairman of Agricola Bacau group, one of the top ten meat processors on the local market.
Horoi, who runs a EUR119 million business with more than 2,500 employees, says that even though his business grew at a slower pace, he tried to keep all the employees.
“Even though our business grew by 27% in 2010 and by 11% in 2011, the human resources remained at the same level. We will continue to hire new people this year because we plan to expand our store network and I am still optimistic about the trend of the local economy in the second half of the year; I’m rather worried about the trend of the global economy,” Horoi added.
The labor market has to recover the more than 550,000 jobs cut in more than three years of crisis, an interval during which consumer spending fell by more than 20% because of the purchasing power decline.
In the last year, however, the number of employees in the industrial sector–which employs the most people working in the private sector, more than 1.2 million-rose by 41,700.
The industry was followed by the construction sector, with more than 32,000 people hired, and commerce, where the number of employees rose by 30,000. The public sector, on the other hand, lost more than 36,000 employees.
With the start of the electoral campaign, politicians have already begun suggesting steps, which they say would create jobs if they were elected. The Social-Liberal Union (USL) for instance, proposes creation of one million jobs, a 5% cut of social security contributions and raising the minimum wage from 700 lei (some EUR150) to RON800 or RON840 per month.
“The government should manage the funds it has much more carefully, because it keeps on making unproductive expenses and investments. The only step, in my opinion, which might have a positive impact on the business sector is for VAT to revert to 19% or even lower for food products, so that consumers would regain trust in the economy and consumer spending would increase,” Sarantis’ Tudorache said.
He believes it is difficult to say whether the economy will do better in the second half of the year given the unpredictability of the euro zone economy and the exchange rate volatility. Sarantis currently has 307 employees, almost 80 fewer than in 2008 and 2009, when the company posted its best financial results.
Meda Prod 98’s Florin Rizea, too, is pessimistic about the steps the government suggested, saying, “their intentions are different, anyway”.
“There is no action that would help us right away, but an entire plan of action. The big cash flow problems can be easily solved by steps such as collecting the VAT upon billing, to avoid us financing our business via high-interest loans,” Rizea said.
(English version by Loredana Fratila-Cristescu)