“You take people from the street and get them to mix the dough to make bread, but they don’t have the minimal theoretical knowledge. They only learn how to do things mechanically. Because everyone is a graduate of higher education,” says Ioan Popa, owner of meat producer Transavia, quoted by BUSINESS Magazin (www.bmag.ro).
In turn, Maria Grapini, general manager of textile manufacturer Pasmatex, says the decision of the Education Ministry to give up vocational schools had a disastrous effect for many employers, who had to find solutions using their own resources because they cannot do without people skilled for a particular craft.
The textile industry business she manages suffers because of the lack of vocational school graduates. Grapini would need weavers or tailors, but she cannot find people with the required skills on the market, and the people she employed when the company was established are now old and need to be replaced.
On the other hand, candidates who apply have university diplomas and would under no circumstances work on the production line and be paid the corresponding wages.
“There are too many university graduates. In a company you cannot use only higher-education graduates. We also need operators, while those who graduated from the Textile Faculty want more,” Grapini comments.
Under the circumstances, there is only one option for industrialists, who are the first to be affected by the disappearance of “skilled workers”, employing unskilled workers from the market and training them using their own resources.
“It is not easy at all to take someone who doesn’t know anything about the job and teach them everything from scratch. They need to have a trainer for at least three months during which time they don’t produce anything, although I have to pay them RON1,000 per month (around EUR230),” explains the general manager of Pasmatex and president of the Federation of Textile, Clothing and Leather Products Owners.
Maria Grapini says Pasmatex has already received the certification to train people in the sector and has created its own vocational school.
Staff fluctuation stands at 65-70% in plants
These measures often prove pointless because many people don’t even stay with the company after they have finished their specialization either because they are not skilled in using the equipment or because they simply are not drawn to the job.
Grapini talks about a fluctuation rate of 65%-70% at the company she runs, which makes the effort of training people all the more costly.
This is not just about wages paid for nothing during the months of training, it is also about taxes paid to the state for those people, especially since the whole process needs to then be resumed.
Pressured by businesspeople and aware that a solid education system needs to be able to train not only specialists, but also skilled workers, the Education Ministry appears to reconsider its position on the need for vocational schools.
“There is a plan at ministry level to revive vocational education. But we don’t know when exactly these schools will be reintroduced into the system,” representatives of the Education Ministry told BUSINESS Magazin. Although the institution’s website still includes the category “Professional education – vocational schools,” the latest information dates back to 2007 and 2008. Nothing new since then. But the ministry’s promises don’t mean a lot to businesspeople.
“They call us for meetings, but this is just formal. Those who are supposed to listen to us talk on the phone, nobody writes anything down, nobody takes anything home from the meeting or sends the message on. We sit there for hours and then rushed decisions are taken,” says businessman Ioan Popa.
The blame must not be placed entirely on the ministry, because for a long time employers used to say one of the make or break conditions for getting a job is a university diploma.
In addition, the increasingly easy access to higher education has led to high school graduates choosing this path, which promised more chances for a solid career and higher income.
The fact that at the moment there is a high number of unemployed from among university graduates proves that the education system has its faults and that its structure encouraged the disappearance of skilled workers whom many companies now say they need.
In addition, many skilled workers who had trained in the old vocational schools understood that abroad they could do the same work for several times higher wages, so they left.
Even if the ministry reopens vocational schools, it is hard to believe the problem would be solved. First of all, one must find a way to make vocational schools attractive for young people.
(English version by Daniela Stoican)