The flip side: Fuels become more expensive. Costs of every company in the economy go up and profit margins go down. Prices of goods go up. Consumer spending and trade decline. Economic growth slows down. State budget revenue goes down, too.

The increase in fuel prices was the main growth driver for the increase of Petrom’s profit, which amounted to 2.92 billion lei (EUR670 million) in the first nine months, double the profit of the corresponding period of last year.

Petrom’s sales went up 23% to RON16.2 billion (EUR3.72 billion), even though the volume of fuel sales fell 2%, according to the quarterly report filed with the Bucharest Stock Exchange.

The better results of Petrom are good news to its shareholders, the Austrian OMV group, which owns 51%, the Romanian government and Fondul Proprietatea, which own 20% each. They will collect higher dividends next year.

What is the cost of all this, though? The rise in fuel prices is bad news to the economy. Transportation costs have increased for every local economic operator over the past year. This was further reflected in the final product prices or in the decline in profit margins of manufacturers, and especially of agricultural producers. More expensive products led to lower sales, at least in volume, hence a decline in trade.

What the Austrians and the other Petrom shareholders gained on the one hand translates into losses for other companies or in lower consumer spending, therefore causes economic growth to slow down. Some of these profits, of course, return to the economy in form of investments made by Petrom, which keep companies providing oil industry equipment or services busy, so that the final effect on the economy is hard to quantify, analysts say.

“The rise in fuel prices makes goods expensive. People pay more for gas and are left with less money to buy other things, hence a consumer spending decline effect,” says financial analyst Dragos Cabat. “On the other hand, higher profits mean higher revenue for the government and part of the money goes back into the economy as investments. The exact impact on the GDP is hard to estimate.”

How the Austrians explain Petrom’s profit growth

When presenting Petrom’s results, the company’s officials say that the profit increased because of the rise in oil price worldwide.

Daniel Turnheim, Petrom’s chief financial officer, says that the company benefited from a strong oil price along with cost control measures. The closure of the Arpechim refinery is also part of the reason why the profit was up. Petrom saw a higher hydrocarbon production on the exploration and production segment, as well, and its good results are also because of the one billion investments made every year.

“Oil is our main profit center and as long as the oil price stays up we will do well.”

The company’s reports make no mention of the gas or diesel price trend, even though this is the main growth driver of the profit. That is because Petrom is not selling oil at the pump and if it did not raise the price of gas every time the oil price increases, it would not post such profits.

Turnheim explained that oil prices had gone up 14% from January through October. International diesel quotes rose by 14%, which translated in an 11% increase of the pump price. International gas quotes rose by 10% in lei and the pump price increased by 10% in the January-October period. Petrom’s prices factor in international quotes, taxes and competition on the market.

Petrom’s production costs, however, are much slower to increase, though. The average cost per oil barrel drilled in the third quarter was $16.61, 8% higher than in the same time of 2010. Average price collected for the oil rose by 38% to $94.32/barrel.

Who stands to gain if Petrom makes higher profit?

The majority shareholder, Austrian OMV group is the main winner, because higher profit for Petrom means higher profit for OMV, too. Petrom contributed 55% of OMV’s earnings before interests and taxes (EBIT) in the third quarter. OMV shareholders, too, stand to gain, because they will collect higher dividends, as will Petrom’s minority shareholders.

Economy Ministry and Fondul Proprietatea each own 20% in Petrom. The other minority shareholders of Petrom should benefit, too, at least in theory. However, Petrom’s record profit announcement did not drive its stock price up, which is the same as at the beginning of the year. Moreover, the government failed to sell 9.84% in the company on the stock market in July.

The government stands to gain by collecting a higher profit tax. The profit tax Petrom paid in the first nine months of 2011 doubled from RON300 million (EUR69 million) to RON600 million (EUR138 million).

Who stands to lose because of the higher fuel price?

The category of losers is much wider, though. The rise in fuel prices affects everyone, more or less. Those most hurt by it are carriers, farmers and food industry companies, as well as construction materials makers.

“The diesel price has been going up year after year. When I build the budget I have one price, when I make the purchases, I have a higher price,” says Adrian Porumboiu, owner of Comcereal Vaslui and of Racova group, one of the largest farming companies in Romania. “The effect is definitely negative to us. I use about 6,500-7,000 tons of diesel oil in [my] farming [business] every year. You do the math.”

“The rise in fuel prices does not affect us much, but very much actually, because transportation spending accounts for 10% to 20% of our revenue. We have two segments [of our business] where fuel consumption is high: extraction of raw materials from quarries and delivery to customers throughout the country,” says Iulian Mangalagiu, general manager of Ceramica Iasi, one of the largest brick makers in Romania.

“Carriers we have contracts with raise prices per kilometer because of the higher fuel price, otherwise they wouldn’t be able to cope. This eventually hurts our bottom line.”

Fuel prices are an important component of a stable economic environment, as are energy and natural gas prices, Mangalagiu added. “We need stability to attract foreign investors.” (EUR1=RON4.3537)

(English version by Loredana Fratila-Cristescu)