This move, dictated by Nokia’s chief executive Stephen Elop from his office in Helsinki and especially by the trends on the international cell phone market, where Nokia has lost a lot of ground to rivals over the last few years, risks jeopardizing the whole structure thrown together by the authorities in Bucharest and the efforts of the local business sector to pull the economy out of the crisis.

It is therefore no wonder that Prime Minister Emil Boc called his ministers for an emergency government meeting on Wednesday night to discuss the implications of the situation in Jucu.

The decision of Nokia, which some analysts had seen coming as early this spring when it had closed the research center in Cluj and fired 120 programmers, is putting the authorities in a very complicated position, as they now have to look for a replacement as fast as possible to counteract the effects.

The negative effects will first show in macroeconomic figures, because Nokia, which had reached EUR1.6 billion revenue in only three years, accounts for about 5% of Romania’s exports and 0.25% to 1% of its gross domestic product (GDP). The country’s economy would not have achieved the tentative growth of the last quarter of 2010 without Nokia’s phones made in Jucu and Boc would not have be able to have triumphantly state in March recession was over.

Yet the much more serious signal Nokia’s departure sends out is that Romania needs a new economic growth model and can no longer rely on foreign investors, which need years to decide whether to bring their money here and a few days to take it and leave for somewhere else. In addition, global turmoil makes departures occur more frequently. Even President Traian Basescu said on Wednesday that plant closings might happen in other industries, too.

Romania has been malfunctioning for a while but “we have yet to wake up to reality,” believes Doru Lionachescu, main partner of boutique investment bank Capital Partners. “Unless Romania wakes up to reality and we start being competitive not only locally but also internationally, we will see more exits of international groups.” Exits will happen because of the decline of the market, too, as the Romanian market is no longer as important, he added.

Nokia’s decision to close the plant in Jucu was brought about by the decline of the stock market and by the competition on the smartphone segment, believes Viorel Gavrea, general manger of Tetarom, the industrial park hosting the company’s plant.

“After they made the first phone in February 2008, nobody expected the plant to close in three years. I believe a bad management decision was made at the time, otherwise I can’t explain it,” Gavrea said. “What happened to Nokia worldwide, the stock market decline and the competition on the smartphone market led to this decision.”

Gavrea says Nokia had 1,700 permanent employees and the number of people working in its plant would go up to 4,000 during peak manufacturing periods before Easter and Christmas.

The businesses affected by Nokia’s departure include carriers DB Schenker Romtrans and E Van Wijk, which have transport contracts signed with the company. The representatives of the two carriers had not provided any comment by the time the story was ready for posting.

Nokia’s decision caused heated emotions among entrepreneurs in Cluj, who pointed out for the first time the huge differences in how authorities treat multinationals and local businesses.

“They won’t even pay attention to us, while they built everything for Nokia, from roads to power and gas grids. Nobody welcomes us with open arms somewhere else, on the contrary,” said Gabriel Carlig, owner of textile business Jolidon, one of the few brands that dared expand abroad. “What’s more, we don’t get the support the authorities show to multinationals.”

Carlig says that what puzzles him is that the decision had already been made and announced in a very short time, whereas in other countries, talks are held with governments and local communities, and the social impact is examined.

Stefan Gadola, vice-president of Energobit, one of the first private companies set up in Cluj, sees Nokia’s departure as a signal “we are at the mercy of multinationals.”

On the other hand, ING Bank’s chief economist Nicolae Chidesciuc says that Romania cannot develop without foreign capital over the next twenty to thirty years considering it does not have domestic capital resources to allow it to grow like an emerging economy, so that it is important to attract capital and keep it here to the extent such things depend on the authorities in Romania.

On the other hand, Ionut Dumitru, chief economist of Raiffeisen Bank believes the impact of the closing of Nokia’s plant in Cluj is “modest” strictly economically speaking; the most important negative consequences have to do with perception among foreign investors and the social impact of the layoffs.

(English version by Loredana Frățilă-Cristescu)