In Romania telecom prices and profit margins are too low and the number of significant players too large for the market to be able to absorb another foreign player in the telecom auction for radio spectrum licenses, which is set to start on September 10, says Yorgos Ioannidis, the manager who ran Romtelecom for four years and a half. Romtelecom is one of the largest communications companies in Romania.

“Romania is one of the most competitive markets in the world, prices and margins are very low and there are already four significant players in the market. Hence getting into such a market is very challenging for any new player,” Ioannidis said. After leaving Romtelecom in June 2011, Ioannidis became vicepresident for telecom and media in an investment company in Azerbaijan and member of the board of companies in Romania.

The communications regulatory authority (ANCOM) this month organizes the largest radio spectrum auction in Romanian history, selling licenses in several frequency bands – including for 4G services – until 2029.

Despite rumors and official statements concerning the interest of Chinese, Arab or even US companies, the only bidders in the auction are existing players on the market (Cosmote, Orange, RCS&RDS and Vodafone) plus a small player (2K Telecom – owned by the family of businessman Sebastian Ghita), who will however not bid for the most valuable licenses priced at tens of millions of euros.

While Marius Fecioru – secretary of state in the Communications Ministry until May – who announced at the beginning of the year that “China Mobile, AT&T, M3 Group and Telenor” were interested in the Romanian auction – blamed the failure of the auction on political conflicts, Ioannidis says the main reasons are the low prices and margins and high competition.

“If an investor cannot foresee that within a reasonable time frame it will be able to breakeven and become profitable, it is not incentivized enough to invest in the specific market. I believe what I just described is the main reason for the limited interest to the spectrum auction,” said the former Romtelecom boss.

The Romanian telecom market was worth a total of EUR3.5 billion last year, with its largest segments being mobile telephony (EUR1.3 billion), internet access (EUR486 million), fixed telephony (EUR385 million) and TV retransmission services (EUR370 million).

The largest players on the Romanian telecom market are the local subsidiaries of international groups Orange and Vodafone, followed by Cosmote and Romtelecom (controlled by Greece’s OTE and Germany’s Deutsche Telekom), RCS&RDS – an operator controlled by Romanian Zoltan Teszari, and US-held UPC. Out of all these companies, in 2011 only Orange and Vodafone made a profit, while the rest of operators recorded losses, according to Finance Ministry data. Orange and Vodafone record an average monthly revenue per customer (ARPU) of around EUR7, according to companies’ financial reports.

After three consecutive years of decline (2009-2011) in recession, the Romanian telecom market could stabilize this year, according to estimates of local companies.

Asked if he expects the auction to cause significant changes on the Romanian market, Ioannidis answered he did not foresee the possibility of dramatic changes.

“But the allocation or re-allocation of the 900 MHz spectrum might have an impact,” Ioannidis said. He added that in his opinion the emergence of a new significant player on the mobile telephony market – a fifth one – would have major effects on the industry’s profitability.

“The only further comment I can make is that a fifth license, which would mean further competition, could totally ruin the market.”

(English version by Daniela Stoican)