Such a treaty between Romania and Sweden allowed the Micula bothers to sue Romania at the arbitral tribunal in Washington.

The EC sent letters of formal notice to Austria, the Netherlands, Romania, Slovakia and Sweden, requesting them to bring the intra-EU bilateral investment treaties between them to an end. Many of these treaties were agreed in the 1990s, before the EU enlargements of 2004, 2007 and 2013.

“This is not a new issue as the Commission has consistently and over a number of years pointed out to all Member States that intra-EU BITs are incompatible with EU law ,” the commission said in a statement Thursday.

Bilateral Investment Treaties (BITs) set the terms and conditions for investments between two states. There are still around 200 bilateral investment treaties in force between EU member states.

Most of them date back to the 1990s when one or both countries were not yet a member of the EU. Their aim was to encourage investments by offering reciprocal guarantees against political risks which might negatively affect those investments.

These BITs are out of date inside a single market of 28 countries. The current proceedings deal only with intra-EU BITs and do not concern BITs that exist between EU member states and third countries, the Commission explained.

While intra-EU BITs were not used much for the first years after enlargement, we have seen a renewed reliance by some investors on these treaties recently, the EC said. For instance, one recent arbitration proceeding based on an intra-EU BIT has produced an outcome that the Commission considers incompatible with EU law, as the arbitral award constitutes illegal state aid.

The arbitral tribunal in the Micula case ordered Romania to pay damages to a Swedish investor, ignoring the Commission’s position that such an award would infringe EU state aid rules.