The Romanian Lottery helped security firm Shelter Security win an auction for an integrated security system by setting restrictive technical criteria. Although the offer submitted by Shelter Security was not eligible, the firm won the auction and was awarded a RON45.96 million contract, reads the Court of Accounts’ 2010 report.

Moreover, the products and the monitoring software applications the firm provided were overvalued, and some were never used, reveals the document.

After the contract was signed, the Romanian Lottery and the security firm signed two additional acts which tripled monitoring and intervention tariffs and increased the value of the contract by 45%. The damage caused to the Lottery is estimated at RON44.14 million, according to the report.

According to data available on www.e-licitatie.ro, the contract was awarded in January 2010 and was valid for one and a half years.

Another contract which caused losses to the Lottery was signed in 2008 with Form Trade SRL, which didn’t have the financial resources needed to carry out the contract, reads the report. Losses rise to RON25.2 million.

According to the Finance Ministry data, Form Trade SRL based in Focsani, filed no financial statements in 2009 and 2010. In 2008, the firm registered losses of RON631.

The Lottery lost RON12.03 million from a contract signed with law firm Ratiu&Ratiu.

According to the Court of Accounts, the Lottery must recover RON1.21 million, which represents unjustified pay to 40 managers.

The company must also recover RON3.22 million which represents the difference between the purchase price of cars bought by the Lottery and the selling price charged by car dealer Radacini Motors SRL.

The report shows that the Lottery helped Radacini Motors win an auction for a car supply contract by setting technical characteristics that did not correspond to the types of cars marketed in Romania.

Radacini Motors SRL was the sole bidder and won the auction although its bid was not eligible. The contract awarded by the Lottery to buy 182 cars was worth RON15.72 million. The car purchase prices were higher than the selling prices charged by Radacini Motors when it made the offer, and losses reached RON3.22 million, reads the report.

In 2010, the Lottery posted turnover of RON1.1 billion, down 22.7% on the year and its net profit fell 19.5% to RON121.15 million. (EUR1=RON4.3532)