From Portugal to Slovakia utility companies are forced to shut down their gas-fired power plants or keep them operating at low capacity, while operators of coal-fired plants announce profits.

In Romania, however, the cost of a ton of black coal is 20% higher than on the international market, and companies using lignite to generate power complain about the unfair competition of gas-fired plants and renewable energy producers that get subsidies from the government.

The only thermoelectric power plants running on black coal in Romania are those in the Complexul Energetic Hunedoara (Hunedoara Energy Complex), a company created by the merger of Compania Nationala a Huilei (National Black Coal Company) Petrosani and thermoelectric power plants Mintia and Paroseni last year.

According to the energy market regulator ANRE, the complex has the highest energy generation cost of the entire system, 271 lei (EUR61)/MWh, with fuel accounting for most of it.

“We are trying to keep our gigacalorie cost (coal cost i.e.) at RON90 to RON95 this year,” said Nicolae Dragoi, former general manager of CNH Petrosani and now deputy general manager of CE Hunedoara.

One ton of black coal equals 3.5 gigacalories, according experts in this field. Therefore the production cost per ton of black coal can be put at about RON332.5.

Sale prices to thermoelectric power plants stood at RON58 to RON67 per gigacalorie in 2009-2012, according to the available information, while in 2012 the mining cost was RON87 per gigacalorie, lower than this year.

On the other hand, on the European Energy Exchange in Leipzig, the biggest such market in Europe, one ton of black coal deliverable in November was trading at $79.75 recently, over 20% less than the cost of black coal mined in Romania, but close to the price CNH got from power plants in 2012.

This brings out the problem of the lack of restructuring again. The management of CE Hunedoara reassured that costs could drop in two years following mining investments.

“The price of coal dropped in Europe compared with two years ago because of the flood of cheap American coal. I talked with Polish companies, which said the same thing: their market is full of US coal, too.”

The thermoelectric power plant in Mintia preferred to import coal in the last few years instead of buying it from the mines in Jiu Valley (SW Romania) because of better prices, according to the information available.

CE Hunedoara general manager Daniel Andronache said the company was not longer importing any coal.

“That happened a long time ago. Meanwhile those stocks have become low so we buy the entire output of Inchideri (Societatea Inchideri Mine Valea Jiului, the company created to supervise the closing of non-profitable mines in the area i.e.),” Andronache says.

“I’ve got 5,000 people mining coal for me, what can I do? I’ve got domestic production, even though it is more expensive. It’s a management mistake, I believe, to drop domestic production and rely on imports.”

The management of the company added they were working on cutting costs, which should happen in about two years.

“We are trying to lower the price in a year or two by making mining investments,” CE Hunedoara deputy general manager said.

Second most expensive power comes from the Complexul Energetic Oltenia (Oltenia Energy Complex, south of the country) formed by the merger of lignite mines in the region and the biggest thermoelectric power plants in Romania: Turceni, Rovinari and Craiova.

The cost of the power generated by lignite-fired plants is RON191/MWh, according to the energy market regulator.

“The generation costs of the power plants now part of the Complexul Energetic Oltenia have been on the rise at all plants, driven by the increase in the prices of cooling water, fuel oil and natural gas, materials, fuels, transportation, equipment and services and the additional green and CO2 certificate taxes,” the company officials say without providing details about a trend of costs over the last five years.

They added the Rovinari power plant has always had the lowest generation costs, because it can take its coal straight from the mine. They added the price per ton of lignite rose 4% in 2009-2013.

“There is no price set on the international markets for the lignite used to generate power, only for superior coal. There can be no international comparison because there are no similarities,” the company officials added.

Coal-fired power plants had to face a number of challenges this year. The very good year hydropower plants had and the clean energy production that the country’s energy system prioritizes over other types of power almost drove them out of the market in the first part of the year.

Moreover, last fall, the government agreed to an aid for Romania’s two natural gas producers, OMV Petrom and Romgaz, allowing them to use only domestically drilled gas to generate electricity, which means lower costs than if they were to use a mix of Romanian and Russian gas.

CE Oltenia representatives say their power would actually be cheaper had the two not benefited from state aid.

“All these things caused the financial performance of CE Oltenia to deteriorate,” they said.

Experts in the industry, however, say that even without the state aid that Petrom and Romgaz get, the gas is cheaper in Romania than in Europe, anyway.

“Our producers still get gas at significantly lower prices than in Europe. At the same time, our coal is much more inefficient and our equipment has much worse yields,” says Jean Constantinescu, analyst and former ANRE chairman.

European Commission data verify that industrial consumers in Romania pay the lowest natural gas price in the entire EU, EUR27.9/MWh. In Poland and Germany, which rely on coal for a lot for their electricity, industrial consumers paid double as much, EUR42.5 and EUR54/MWh in the second half of last year.

Another problem for the local thermoelectric power plants is that they were built in the ‘70s and the ‘80s using older designs, so their yields are about 30%. Coal-fired power plants in Western Europe operate at more than 50% yields.

Coal is Romania’s most plentiful energy resource, as the country has enough black coal to last it 230 years and enough lignite for 47 years. Oil and gas reserves should be depleted in 15 years unless new major discoveries are made.

(English version by Loredana Fratila-Cristescu)